Get the newsletter
Microsoft · Software · Filed Mar 25, 2025 · USPTO published Oct 1, 2026 · Oct 1 release

Microsoft Patents a Way to Catch Bugs in the Tools That Find Bugs

Code-checking software is supposed to catch errors before they reach you, but what happens when the checker itself is wrong? Microsoft has filed a patent for a system that automatically spots when a code analysis tool is lying.

A validation system compares abstract and concrete states of a test program to identify mismatches and generate alerts. Drawing from patent filing US 2026/0300142 A1.
A validation system compares abstract and concrete states of a test program to identify mismatches and generate alerts.All 12 drawings ↓
Publication number
US 2026/0300142 A1(US20260300142A1)
Applicant
MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING, LLC
Filed · Published
Mar 25, 2025 · Oct 1, 2026
Inventors
Alan Thomas Gavin JOWETT, Daniel Michael AGUN JR.
Status when we published
Waiting for an examiner
Document
20 claims
US classification
717/124

What Microsoft's code-checker validation actually does

Every time a developer ships an update to an app on your phone, automated tools scan that code looking for mistakes before a human ever reviews it. Those tools are trusted almost blindly, but they can have their own bugs, and when they do, real errors slip through to you.

Microsoft's patent describes a system that runs the same code through two different lenses at once. One lens is the analysis tool itself, which predicts what a piece of code should do based on math and logic. The other lens is an actual machine that runs the code and reports what it actually does. If the two answers disagree, the system fires an alert pointing to exactly which line of code caused the disagreement.

The practical idea is simple: check the checker. By comparing the predicted result with the real result automatically, Microsoft's system can catch errors in analysis tools that would otherwise go undetected for months or years.

From the filing · THE ABSTRACT
A static analysis tool is an automated software tool that evaluates the behavior of a given computer program using rigorous mathematical methods and without executing the program.

Translation: It analyzes code using math without actually running it.

How the abstract and concrete states get compared

The patent describes a validation method built around a deliberate head-to-head comparison. A test program with known inputs is fed to two separate systems simultaneously.

The first system is the static analysis tool, software that reads code without running it. It uses formal mathematical reasoning to predict what value each instruction in the program should produce. That prediction is called the abstract state (think of it as the tool's best educated guess about what the code will do).

The second system is a concrete implementation, typically a virtual machine that actually executes the test program line by line and records what each instruction actually produced. That real-world output is called the concrete state.

After each instruction, the patent's method compares the two states. If the static tool predicted a value of, say, 42 but the machine produced 43, that mismatch is flagged immediately. The system generates an alert that identifies the specific instruction where the disagreement occurred, giving engineers a precise starting point for diagnosing what went wrong in the analysis tool itself.

From the filing · CLAIM 1
… identifying a mismatch between the concrete state and the abstract state at the instruction of the test program, wherein the mismatch is identified by the by specific value included in the concrete state being different from the expected value defined by the abstract state …

Translation: It flags an error when the tool's prediction does not match what the code actually does.

What this means for software you rely on daily

Static analysis tools are embedded deep in the software pipelines that build the apps, operating systems, and cloud services you use every day. A flaw in one of those tools does not just affect one piece of code: it can approve broken code across thousands of programs for as long as the flaw goes undetected.

For end users, that means a validated analysis tool is a quieter form of protection, one that works before a developer even thinks to check. Microsoft's system would make it easier to run these checks continuously and automatically, rather than relying on a human to eventually notice that a tool started producing wrong answers. The benefit is not dramatic or visible; it shows up as fewer mysterious app crashes and security gaps that never happen.

Microsoft filed its 36th application we've tracked in our AI teams working together watchlist since May, building on grading and repairing agents and picking the right helpers.

Source: US 2026/0300142 A1 at the USPTO (PDF). Full patent text and figures are in the official publication.

Get our take in your Top Stories

Liked this breakdown? Add Patentlyze as a preferred source on Google, and our plain-English take shows up more often in your Top Stories the next time Microsoft patent news breaks.

There are more where this came from

We read every patent application Big Tech publishes and send you the ones worth knowing. Plain English, free, every week.

The drawings · 12 sheets

12 drawing sheets from US 2026/0300142 A1 · click any drawing to enlarge

Validation system overview, drawing sheet 1 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 1 Validation system overview
Static analysis of test program, drawing sheet 2 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 2 Static analysis of test program
Abstract and concrete state comparison, drawing sheet 3 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 3 Abstract and concrete state comparison
Concrete implementation outputs, drawing sheet 4 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 4 Concrete implementation outputs
Expected behavior and mismatch, drawing sheet 5 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 5 Expected behavior and mismatch
Verified test program execution, drawing sheet 6 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 6 Verified test program execution
Unsafe operation alert, drawing sheet 7 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 7 Unsafe operation alert
Test program generator with machine learning, drawing sheet 8 from US 2026/0300142 A1
Sheet 8 Test program generator with machine learning
Show the other 4 sheets
Microsoft Patents a Way to Catch Bugs in the Tools That Find Bugs patent drawing, sheet 9
Sheet 9
Microsoft Patents a Way to Catch Bugs in the Tools That Find Bugs patent drawing, sheet 10
Sheet 10
Microsoft Patents a Way to Catch Bugs in the Tools That Find Bugs patent drawing, sheet 11
Sheet 11
Microsoft Patents a Way to Catch Bugs in the Tools That Find Bugs patent drawing, sheet 12
Sheet 12
Patent filing page

Watchlists this filing belongs to

All watchlists →
Reader comments

No comments yet

Start the discussion

Real name or a handle, either is fine. Comments are read by a person before they appear, so allow a little time. Keep it about the filing.